ext_5065 ([identity profile] witchwillow.livejournal.com) wrote in [community profile] lkh_lashouts2006-12-03 02:03 pm

BookFlog / Book Review

"The latest on best-seller Hamilton's series featuring Meredith Gentry, the fairie princess/PI in the Unseelie Court, reads sorta like fan fiction."




"Newbies will struggle to digest the plot; In exchange for the lives of captured enemies, Gentry bets her evil Aunt Adais, Queen of Air and Darknesss, that she can bring back to life their long-dead gardens--and produce an heir-- by boinking the guards, washed-up jester Abeloec and rough 'n' ready Mistral. But everyone will enjoy the marathon, 40-page opening sex scene. While we bow to proud Merry's stamina, we'd love to see her lead men (or goblins) into battle with more than just her sex appeal." C+

-- Entertainment Weekly's (#910, Dec 8 2006) Mandi Bierly

_____________

Seems pretty damn insulting to fanfiction to me. But look it's not just us who are 'total haters, omg we suck'

[identity profile] ladymina.livejournal.com 2006-12-03 07:48 pm (UTC)(link)
should have said bad fanfiction or just mentioned the mary-sue factor
there is a lot of good fanfiction out there, well ok there is a lot of bad fanfic out there, too but meh you can't have everything ...